Film vs Film

[Claireofthemoon]

Originally Posted by Gort

Alicante for 5 days for the Spain v Scotland game. Should be a giggle apart from the result lol

Have a great time.

[re93animator]

Haven't seen either of the current ones.

Originally Posted by Claireofthemoon

Have a great time.

Cheerz.

Life Of David Gale was ok, haven't seen the other one.

[Claireofthemoon]

Since we have no one else that wants to be added to the list, I guess this thread will sleep for awhile and possibly die.

Claireofthemoon
Re93animator

[re93animator]

Originally Posted by Claireofthemoon

Since we have no one else that wants to be added to the list, I guess this thread will sleep for awhile and possibly die.

Could we possibly just change it up a bit, to spark some interest in it again? Like putting up comparisons with more than two films, or doing a tournament thing.

[Claireofthemoon]

Sure. Either one would be fine with me.

[re93animator]

After thinking about it a little, I think the forum is too small for a tournament at the moment, but here's a comparison between a few that I assume most have seen:

Vs.

Between Scorsese and Tarantino, which director do you think had the better gangster genre output in the 90's?

I think Pulp Fiction is the best of the four, and that Tarantino's films were more unconventional and creative, but I also think RD is the weakest of the four. It's a toss up, but I'm going with Goodfellas and Casino.

[bulletproof]

I can't think of a tougher choice. I would have to end up basing my opinion on which ones I have seen more so I guess I would have to go with Goodfellas and Casino as well.

[Pelicula]

Quentin Tarantino all the way. Adore Goodfellas but Tarantino I find a lot more interesting. Reservoir Dogs is my favourite out of the four. In the 90s, Tarantino's films were more relevant and influencial compared to Scorseses two I think.

So it's Pulp Fiction, and Reservoir Dogs for my vote.

[DrPepper21]

Tarantino